November 19, 2026
On Aspenwood Drive at Country Pointe Plainview, a two-bedroom condo suite on the first floor of an elevator building is listed at $999,999 for 1,335 square feet. That works out to about $749 a square foot as of mid-November 2026. Across all current listings in Plainview, the average asking price is $583 a square foot, on homes averaging 2,175 square feet and built, on average, in 1975.
So a longtime Plainview owner who moves into a newer condo a few miles away pays more for each foot, not less. The suite's annual tax bill is $5,512. The average across Plainview listings is $16,300. In Plainview, a downsize changes the monthly bill more than the purchase price, and the type of building you choose affects that bill as much as the size of the home.
Across Nassau County, condos generally cost less than houses. OneKey MLS's third-quarter 2026 report for Nassau puts the median single-family sale price at $880,000 and the median condo price at $802,500. The condo figure was down 3.5 percent from the same quarter of 2025. If you take that county pattern into a Plainview search, you would expect a condo to free up cash.
Country Pointe Plainview doesn't follow that pattern. On Signature Premier Properties' Country Pointe Plainview page, the average listing as of mid-November 2026 is $1,000,000 for 1,335 square feet, or $749 a square foot, with an average year built of 2020. The current listings run higher than that average. A 1,379-square-foot condo suite at 21201 Aspenwood Drive, listed November 11, 2026, is asking $1,250,000, about $906 a square foot. A two-bedroom villa at 43101 Silver Birch Lane, listed October 29, is asking $1,750,000 for 2,178 square feet. One closed sale shows where buyers have actually paid. A 1,989-square-foot, three-bedroom villa at 86202 Spruce Pond Circle sold for $1,640,000 on January 2, 2026, roughly $825 a square foot.
Part of the reason is age. The average Plainview listing was built in 1975, and the average Country Pointe listing was built in 2020. Part of it is what comes with the address. The Aspenwood suite's listing describes underground parking with a dedicated space, two private storage units, and a 29,000-square-foot clubhouse with a fitness center, aerobics studio, card rooms, game room, sports bar, ballroom and theater, plus two heated pools and tennis, pickleball and bocce courts. Whatever the mix, someone selling a house that lists near Plainview's average of $1,267,400 and buying the average Country Pointe home would keep about a quarter million dollars. That is less than the drop from roughly 2,175 square feet to roughly 1,335 might suggest.
The monthly numbers favor the condo. Plainview's average listing tax bill of $16,300 a year comes to about $1,358 a month. At 15103 Aspenwood Drive, taxes of $5,512 a year come to about $459 a month. Add the $950 monthly common charge and the total is about $1,409. At 21201 Aspenwood Drive, annual taxes of $3,225 come to about $269 a month, and with the $1,007 common charge the total is about $1,276.
For these two suites, as listed in mid-November 2026, the tax plus the common charge comes to about what the average Plainview listing pays in property tax alone. The house figure here is property tax only. A seller comparing the two should put each house expense they actually pay next to the common charge, and the tax bill next to the tax bill.
These are general figures taken from public listings in mid-November 2026. They are not tax, legal or financial advice, and your own numbers should be confirmed with your accountant, attorney or lender.
At Country Pointe, the common charge depends on the type of building more than on the size of the home. The condo suites are one-level homes in mid-rise elevator buildings with underground parking. The villas are larger, and their monthly charges are lower.
| Home, as listed or sold in 2026 | Type | Size | Price | Monthly common charge | Annual taxes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21201 Aspenwood Dr., listed Nov. 11 | Condo suite | 1,379 sq. ft. | $1,250,000 asking | $1,007 | $3,225 |
| 15103 Aspenwood Dr., listed June 4 | Condo suite | 1,335 sq. ft. | $999,999 asking | $950 | $5,512 |
| 38204 Winterberry Dr., listed Sept. 3 | Upper villa | 1,989 sq. ft. | $1,525,000 asking | $758 | $11,521 |
| 43101 Silver Birch Ln., listed Oct. 29 | Villa | 2,178 sq. ft. | $1,750,000 asking | $676 | $11,093 |
| 86202 Spruce Pond Cir., sold Jan. 2 | Villa | 1,989 sq. ft. | $1,640,000 sold | $656.56 | $7,562 |
Per square foot, the two suites carry about 71 to 73 cents a month in common charges. The three villas carry 31 to 38 cents. Taxes go the other way: the villas pay roughly two to three times as much as the suites. Added together, the Silver Birch villa comes to about $1,600 a month and the Winterberry villa to about $1,718. Both are higher than the suites, but both have more than 600 extra square feet.
For a downsizer, this narrows the decision. Choosing a suite means a lower purchase price and lower taxes, a higher fixed monthly charge, and one-level living with an elevator and indoor parking. Choosing a villa means a higher purchase price and higher taxes in exchange for more space and a smaller common charge. Before comparing two Country Pointe listings on price, it helps to know which type of building each one is in.
Country Pointe holds most of the current inventory, but it is not the only option. As of November 15, 2026, Plainview had five active condo listings: four at Country Pointe and one at The Hamlet at Olde Oyster Bay.
The Hamlet at Olde Oyster Bay changes the numbers again. Its one current listing, at 130 Sagamore Drive, is a five-bedroom, 3.5-bath condo built as a townhouse, with 3,582 square feet and an asking price of $1,748,888. It came on the market in October 2026, with a monthly HOA fee of $751 and annual taxes of $25,684. That comes to about $488 a square foot, below the Plainview average of $583, while the tax bill is well above the Plainview listing average of $16,300. A buyer at The Hamlet keeps a house-sized home and a house-sized tax bill, and an association handles the shared grounds.
The Seasons at Plainview is smaller and older. It was built in 2007 and has 134 homes. Of those, 106 are two-bedroom condos for residents 55 and older, and 28 attached homes are reserved through a first-time homebuyer program. Upper condos are 1,591 square feet with lofts and porches. Lower condos are 1,379 square feet with basements and patios. The community has a two-story, 2,000-square-foot clubhouse and an outdoor pool. The Seasons had no active listing on November 15, 2026, so a buyer who wants to live there is waiting for a home to come up rather than choosing among several.
When both homes are in the same hamlet, the order of the sale and the purchase matters as much as the prices. As of mid-November 2026, Signature Premier's Plainview page shows current listings averaging 54 days on the website. The Country Pointe Plainview page shows an average of 164 days. These are small groups of active listings, not a market forecast. Still, at this moment the house you are leaving belongs to the quicker-moving group, and the condo you want has more company on the market and more time to compare options.
New supply is not the factor here. Long Island Business News reported in March 2024 that Beechwood had sold all 660 market-rate homes at Country Pointe Plainview, at original prices from $650,000 to $1.9 million, and that 90 homes for buyers 62 and older were still to be built. Today's market-rate Country Pointe options are resales, and each one's price, building type and common charge is set by its own listing.
For a Plainview owner, the most useful numbers to get early are what your house is likely to sell for and what you pay each month to own it, all expenses included. A home valuation covers the first. Your tax bill and the last year of house expenses cover the second. With those in hand, the suite-or-villa question and the Country Pointe, Hamlet or Seasons question become a comparison of monthly costs and space. For more on Plainview, see the Plainview neighborhood page and the full 55+ community guide. Readers following the land next to Country Pointe may also want the update on the town park planned for the soccer fields.
If you've lived in Plainview for years and want to know what moving to Country Pointe, The Hamlet or The Seasons would do to your monthly costs, Michelle Norris can go through your house's numbers and these communities with you, one listing at a time. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
From your first consultation to the closing table, Michelle is committed to making your real estate journey smooth, informed, and successful. Whether you're preparing to sell, searching for your next home, or exploring Long Island's 55+ communities, Michelle provides the expertise, strategy, and personal attention needed to achieve your goals.