White clapboard home with a slate-blue entrance, bluestone steps, brick walk, and a mature maple carrying autumn leaves.

Elwood's Pumpkin Patch Started as a Way to Wait for the Christmas Trees

October 29, 2026

"I started this farm as a cut-your-own Christmas tree farm. It takes eight to ten years on Long Island to get a tree to where you might want to buy it," Lee Itzler told the Long Island Press in 2022. "So I started growing pumpkins. It stuck with me."

Most people in Elwood know 1500 East Jericho Turnpike as the place with the pumpkins and the corn maze. That's the newer half of the business. The farm began with the evergreens behind the pumpkin field, and the pumpkins were planted to keep the place going while those trees grew. This weekend is the last pumpkin weekend of 2026. The longer-running business on this land starts up again in late November.

The Pumpkin Ticket Comes With a Ride Through the Trees

Newsday's 2026 pumpkin-picking guide lists Elwood's pumpkin-field admission at $10, and the ticket includes the corn maze. Pumpkins start at $6 each, and the guide describes white, yellow and pink varieties along with gourds. According to the farm's own site, children 3 and under get in free with a parent, pumpkins are priced by size, and the farm doesn't take credit cards.

The one add-on shows how the farm is set up. Newsday lists the wagon ride at $8, and the farm describes it as a tour of "the 22 acre Christmas tree farm." In October, the wagon carries pumpkin visitors past rows of trees that are still years from sale.

Itzler has also kept the pumpkin side small on purpose. The same Long Island Press piece described the bigger operations in Melville, White Post Farms with its petting zoo and F&W Schmitt Family Farm with pony rides, and reported that Itzler keeps his pumpkin picking more peaceful. "My customers come in to get away from that," he told the paper. "They want to pick a pumpkin and have a quiet day with their kids."

A quiet pumpkin patch fits a farm whose main crop is a slow one.

A Crop You Plant a Decade Ahead

Newsday profiled Itzler in December 2012. It described him as a landscape architect with a degree from the state environmental science college in Syracuse, and it said he opened the 22-acre lot in 2007. That profile gave the growing time as 7 to 10 years of tending before a tree is ready to sell. His 2022 estimate was eight to ten years.

On that timeline, a seedling started this fall would reach selling size somewhere between 2034 and 2036.

That timeline explains several of the farm's choices:

  • The species mix. The farm grows Norway spruce, Douglas fir, Fraser fir, blue spruce and Turkish fir, and it lists large Norway spruce and Douglas firs up to about 30 feet tall.
  • The planting method. Itzler told FOX 5 New York that he grows seedlings in pots for several years before setting them in the field, which he says gives them stronger roots. He made the point in a season when other tree farms may have been hurt by a late-summer drought.
  • The handling. The 2012 Newsday profile noted that he belonged to the Cornell Cooperative Integrated Pest Management Program, used minimal pesticides, and tied harvested trees with biodegradable rope instead of plastic netting.

A field that takes most of a decade to produce anything needs income in the meantime. That's the job the pumpkins have done.

Two Seasons, One Gate

The two halves of the year run very differently at the same address.

Pumpkin season Christmas tree season
What it is Pick-your-own pumpkins, corn maze, wagon ride Cut-your-own or precut trees on 22 acres
Time to grow the crop Added because trees take so long About 7 to 10 years, per Itzler
2026 timing Opened Saturday, Sept. 26; last day Sunday, Nov. 1 No 2026 dates posted yet; historically the day after Thanksgiving
Cost $10 admission, $8 wagon ride, pumpkins from $6 Call for prices
Payment Cash only Cash only

The Last Pumpkin Days, by the Calendar

This post goes up on Thursday, October 29, so only four pumpkin days are left in 2026. Newsday lists weekday hours of 3 to 5 p.m. through Friday, Oct. 30, and weekend hours of 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. through Sunday, Nov. 1. On the calendar, that works out to:

  1. Thursday, Oct. 29: 3 to 5 p.m.
  2. Friday, Oct. 30: 3 to 5 p.m.
  3. Saturday, Oct. 31: 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.
  4. Sunday, Nov. 1: 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.

Expect Halloween Saturday to be the busiest. The farm notes that cars usually fit inside, but at peak times visitors may have to park on Jericho Turnpike and walk in. The gate is on the right, about a mile after you turn east onto Jericho Turnpike, coming north from Exit 51 of the Long Island Expressway or Exit 42 of the Northern State Parkway. Bring cash. For questions about hours, the farm's number is (631) 368-8626.

The Weeks Between the Two Seasons

After Nov. 1, the pumpkin season is over and the tree season has not yet been announced. Down the road at the Elwood Public Library, 1929 Jericho Turnpike, two things fall in that gap.

The library is the October collection point for the Greenlawn American Legion's mobile flag drop, which runs Oct. 1 through Nov. 2 during library hours. Worn American flags can be left there for proper retirement. Details are on Huntington Matters.

Registration also opens on publication day, Oct. 29 at 9:30 a.m., for the library's adult "Holiday Honey and Buttermilk Biscuits" class, held Friday, Nov. 6, from 1 to 3 p.m. The listing is on Huntington Now.

When the Gate Opens for Trees

The farm hasn't posted 2026 tree-season dates or hours. Its current site covers the pumpkin schedule and gives only general information about the trees. In the past, sales have started the day after Thanksgiving. Itzler described those first customers to Newsday in 2012, and FOX 5 reported the same start in a later season. This year the day after Thanksgiving is Friday, Nov. 27. That's the farm's past pattern, though, and nothing announced so far confirms it for 2026.

The most recent posted tree hours come from New York Family's November 2025 guide, which listed Saturdays and Sundays from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., by appointment only. It said to call for prices and noted that credit cards aren't accepted. Calling (631) 368-8626 before you go is the safest plan.

FOX 5 reported that the farm draws people from Manhattan to Montauk. For Elwood households, it's a short drive. The farm's site lists what to bring:

  • Your own saw, if you plan to cut the tree yourself. Axes and chainsaws aren't allowed. Without a saw, staff will cut one for you.
  • A blanket to protect the car roof. The farm ties trees to cars at no charge.
  • Cash.

Precut trees are also available, and photography is by permit only.

Itzler's advice for keeping the tree alive at home is just as practical. In the FOX 5 New York segment, he said a freshly cut tree should easily last to Christmas and beyond. He suggested two freshness checks: pull on a branch to see whether needles come off, or scratch the bark to see if it's still green. He also explained which needle drop to worry about:

"All trees naturally drop up to one-third of their needles, and they always come from the inside, so if you have needles dropping on the outside, you have a problem."

He told the station that plenty of water matters, that adding sugar isn't necessary, and that the tree does best away from radiators or anything blowing air. Keep the room as cool as you can and turn the lights off at bedtime. In his words, "Christmas trees won't show death until perhaps a month later." A tree that looks fine on the drive home still needs plenty of water.

Whether your family goes for the last pumpkins this weekend or waits for tree season, places like this farm are part of what makes Elwood feel like home. I love hearing which local traditions matter most to the people I work with. If you're getting ready for a change and want someone who knows these Huntington roads in every season, Michelle Norris would be glad to help. Let's Connect.

Ready for Your Next Move?

From your first consultation to the closing table, Michelle is committed to making your real estate journey smooth, informed, and successful. Whether you're preparing to sell, searching for your next home, or exploring Long Island's 55+ communities, Michelle provides the expertise, strategy, and personal attention needed to achieve your goals.